2004-2014 James F. Jones, Jr., H’14, 2004-2014
​2003-2004 ​ Borden W. Painter, Jr. ’58, H’95
2002-2003 Richard H. Hersh
2001-2002 Ronald R. Thomas H’02, Acting President
1995-2001 Evan S. Dobelle H’01
1994-1995 Borden W. Painter, Jr. ’58, H’95, Acting President
1989-1994 Tom Gerety
1981-1989 James Fairfield English, Jr., H’89
1968-1981 Theodore Davidge Lockwood ’48, H’81
1953-1968 Albert Charles Jacobs H’68
1945-1951 George Keith Funston ’32
1943-1945, 1951-1953 ​Arthur Howard Hughes M’38, H’46, Acting President ​
1920-1943 Remsen Brinckerhoff Ogilby
1915-1916, 1919-1920 Henry Augustus Perkins, Acting President
1904-1919 Flavel Sweeten Luther ’70, H’04
1883-1904 George Williamson Smith H’87
1874-1883 Thomas Ruggles Pynchon ’41
1867-1874 Abner Jackson ’37
1864-1866 John Barrett Kerfoot H’65
1861-1864 Samuel Eliot H’57
1860-1861, 1864, 1866-1867, 1874 ​ John Brocklesby H’45, Acting President ​
1853-1860 Daniel Raynes Goodwin
1848-1853 John Williams ’35
1837-1848 Silas Totten
1831-1837 Nathaniel Sheldon Wheaton
1824-1831 Thomas Church Brownell