2014–2025 Joanne Berger-Sweeney
2004–2014 James F. Jones, Jr. H’14
​2003–2004 ​ Borden W. Painter Jr. ’58, H’95
2002–2003 Richard H. Hersh
2001–2002 Ronald R. Thomas H’02, Acting President
1995–2001 Evan S. Dobelle H’01
1994–1995 Borden W. Painter Jr. ’58, H’95, Acting President
1989–1994 Tom Gerety
1981–1989 James Fairfield English Jr., H’89
1968–1981 Theodore Davidge Lockwood ’48, H’81
1953–1968 Albert Charles Jacobs H’68
1945–1951 George Keith Funston ’32
1943–1945, 1951-1953 ​Arthur Howard Hughes M’38, H’46, Acting President ​
1920–1943 Remsen Brinckerhoff Ogilby
1915–1916, 1919-1920 Henry Augustus Perkins, Acting President
1904–1919 Flavel Sweeten Luther ’70, H’04
1883–1904 George Williamson Smith H’87
1874–1883 Thomas Ruggles Pynchon ’41
1867–1874 Abner Jackson ’37
1864–1866 John Barrett Kerfoot H’65
1861–1864 Samuel Eliot H’57
1860–1861, 1864, 1866-1867, 1874 ​ John Brocklesby H’45, Acting President ​
1853–1860 Daniel Raynes Goodwin
1848–1853 John Williams ’35
1837–1848 Silas Totten
1831–1837 Nathaniel Sheldon Wheaton
1824–1831 Thomas Church Brownell