| Tips for Using the Web
in American Studies
The Internet is no substitute for serious library research.
But the web might give you some topic ideas and access to primary sources.
Below, Kevin Smokler, grad student in American Studies and reviewer
of web sites for the American Studies Association's Crossroads Project,
gives you some dos and don'ts for using the web in your classwork.
DO
-
Still use the library. The web is not a substitute for the piles
of stuff we have in our awesome campus libraries, where, in many places,
you can actually get your hands on the actual manuscripts, letters etc.
If you doubt, try reading your favorite book curled up in bed and then
on a computer screen. Ain't nothing like the real thing. Rather, consider
the web an additional source for large research projects (a term paper),
and as a quick fact checker for small stuff (a homework assignment). For
tips on using the library, see American Studies Library
Resources.
-
Start big and go small. If you're beginning cold, (i.e. I don't
even know who W.E.B. Du Bois is much less am I ready to write a five-pager
about him), a simple search on an engine will get you going. (Yahoo,
Lycos, Altavista,
and Infoseek all offer engines.
Hotbot is easy to use and has broad
coverage.) Almost everyone has a web page these days, so if somewhere in
passing you heard about a Du Bois Institute Fellowship, do a search for
it. Pages almost always have links to other ones like it. To that end...
-
Give yourself plenty of time. The Web might make finding Miles Davis
bootlegs quick and easy but the same cannot be said for research. At its
best, the web is a very powerful compass, indicating quickly where material
can be found. It does not sort it, process it or even vouch for its validity
sometimes. You've got to do that stuff and that takes time. So use the
web as an add-on, not a fallback.
-
Verify the source of the site. Anything coming from a university
is probably okay. An organization, you might want to double check with
a professor. Online journals are sprouting up everywhere so again, I'd
double-check the title with a professor or campus librarian. Anything contributed
to by an established scholar (their books are in the library or assigned
for class) is generally safe.
DON'T
-
Don't use political or interest group or pundit sites as historical
fact. Look, any moron with a computer and basic HTML training can have
a web page. It in no way guarantees the authenticity of the material contained
within. So any site representing a party, guru, cult, or whatever that
speaks in dogma rather than fact, in pronouncements rather than observations
should be avoided. Ask yourself how well does this site back up its claims?
Does it point you to primary resources (original documents) that buttress
its point? Using a crank site in your research is not only bad scholarship
but makes you look like a dodo bird.
-
Don't think you don't have to document a web site. In fact, a web
site footnote should contain not only the URL (address) but also probably
a brief explanation of the site, its format, mission and the date you accessed
it. Many professors still haven't renounced pen and paper and think calling
up info on a computer is a) for sissies and b) of questionable value. Indicate
that this material offers an additional perspective and that your use of
it doesn't say "I couldn't bother going to the library."
-
Don't spend hours searching for answers in the bowels of an enormous
web site. Any site worth its Megahertz will have a search engine or
at least a manageable list of links. These make looking for materials a
relatively easy process. A badly designed site will have an interminable
list of lists with vague, unhelpful headings and data placed in ridiculous
places such as under the webmasters' profile of his pet armadillo. These
sites are a waste and should be avoided.
-
Dont' think that a site exists in a vacuum. Almost without exception,
web sites draw on material that already exists in a conventional fashion.
It's still out there even if it's not on the web. Web sites are helpful
but always icing, never cake. Go to Card
Catalog first.
Good Luck!
-- Kevin Smokler
Home | Top | Know
What You're Reading | What to Look For | Circling
the Image | Hints on Notetaking | Using
Your Notes | Writing Papers &
The Library | Glossary of Terms | Outline
of Site | Credits
|